Stirring controversy hasn't ever been an interest. Sparking thought? One could only ever hope. I had such a teacher, and he was one of my top mentors, in and out of academics. His obvious brilliance, blended with his (also obvious) humility was mesmerizing. I shared the following opinion on a blog post today:
Hello Natalie and crew,
If our toenails are curling at such as the inappropriate usages of the apostrophe; tired idioms; slang; or metathesis (aks for ask), maybe we have other considerations to examine:
As an editing minor in college, a top-notch Linguistics professor made a profound observation in an upper level editing class. It changed me: pointed out my pride, softened my hard-liner opinions and condescension. To paraphrase: "Most people know about 10-20 common grammatical errors, and go around beating the rest of humanity with them all their lives. In fact, most English teachers know little more than 20-30 'pet' grammar rules, and do the same to their students. English is a living language. Those who really know language, grammar and rules well are the most forgiving." I leave you to figure out why.
As an American living in Europe, I guarantee each of you says and does (not say and do) several things, perhaps daily, that would have you lampooned by your European neighbors. I hear of our comparable cultural "naivete's" with regularity!
With a passion for concise usage, I have my own (long list)! Did you read others' comments to this post with interest, as I did, weighing (and perhaps adding) their peeves to your own growing list? Do we hide behind our lists with an internal sigh of relief that we don't commit them? With a self-satisfied assurance that we know better?
I just hope that we are intelligent and compassionate people first. Before being smart. And sassy. Individuals able to humorously temper our idiosyncratic pet-peeves to prevent us from judging (instead of allowing learning, appreciating and connecting with) other people. I find it a fine line between knowing the "list," and wielding it against others in judgment (usually rooted in enmity).
Heaven knows there are enough smart, selfish and opinionated people in the world. Not to mention snarky. Such doesn't reflect education, "good breeding" or a spirit of compassion and grace. Each considerably unattractive - above bad habits, bad language or bad usage. Oh how we betray ourselves!
Friendly greetings from across the pond,
SW
Upon our deaths, how would it be to have been remembered for living with grace? The wonderful Ralph Waldo Emerson speaks my desires masterfully:
How do you measure success? To laugh often, and much; to win the respect of intelligent people and the affection of children; to earn the appreciation of honest critics and endure the betrayal of false friends; to appreciate beauty; to find the best in others; to leave the world a bit better, whether by a healthy child, a redeemed social condition, or a job well done; to know even one other life has breathed because you lived: this is to have succeeded.

